|
________________________________________________________________
Product Reviews:
   
a great general-purpose lense, July 16, 2004
Reviewer: "gecko13"
I bought this lens four years ago and have shot around 6,000 photos with
it (4000 digital, 2000 35mm). Autofocus is very fast and quiet, which is
typical of the Canon USM lenses. I would not recommend a Canon lens that
does not have the ultrasonic motor (USM) focusing. Optics are sharp
throughout the focusing range.
The lens is fairly heavy and after a few months of use, you will likely
find that the weight of the glass is enough to make the lens telescope out
when it's around your neck. If you want a compact lens that will let you
take great pictures in a wide range of settings, this is probably the best
lens you could get for a Canon camera. If you're a pro, you'll probably
have a backpack full of lenses and you're not reading this anyway, so I'm
not talking to you. If you want something you can sling over your shoulder
and not think about when you take the kids to Disney World, get a cheaper,
lighter lens.
The Image Stabilizer (IS) makes the lens a lot more expensive (some lenses
are offered with and without it), so you should know what you're paying
for. Some notes about the Image Stabilizer:
- The image stabilizer itself is basically a spinning lens element (piece
of glass) that acts as a gyroscope. When the lens moves slightly, such as
camera shake caused by your pulse, the gyroscopic element stays put while
the other elements move. Because the gyroscopic element is no longer in
line with the other elements, it effectively bends the light just enough
to compensate for the lens moving.
- Having the IS feature does not mean that you can take crisp photos with
a 1/20 sec exposure while jumping on a trampoline. What it means is that
you can often get away with not carrying a tripod in normal lighting, and
in low light when your photos would be very blurry (assuming you're not
using really fast film), the IS will make the images significantly less
blurry. An obvious corollary is that you can avoid using a flash in many
situations when a flash is undesirable or prohibited.
- The rule of thumb to get crisp photos without image stabilization is
that your shutter speed should not be longer than 1 over your focal
length. So if you are taking a picture zoomed in at 135mm, your shutter
speed needs to be 1/135 sec or faster, and since no camera I know of has a
1/135 setting, that means going up to 1/160 sec (on cameras with stops in
1/3 increments) or faster. The image stabilizer means that you can go 2
f-stops slower than you normally could using the rule I just explained. So
if you're shooting at 135mm and you have the IS switched on, you can shoot
at 1/40 sec instead of 1/160 sec. That means four times as much light goes
past the shutter, or that you can get the same quality results with 1/4 of
the ambient light you would normally need.
- There are some times when you SHOULD NOT use the IS feature. You should
definitely not use it if you are in a car, on a roller coaster, if you are
walking, or in any other situation where the camera is moving or vibrating
a lot. You will get blurrier than normal images because the gyroscopic
element is constantly moving all over the place, trying to prevent the
image from moving. Only have IS switched on when you are using the camera
in a normal, stationary, handheld manner. You should also not use IS when
you are using a tripod, or when you have the camera resting on a
vibration-less surface for an image. The reason is that the gyroscopic
element will be spinning even though it's not needed, and while this isn't
really bad, the motion could decrease photo quality (I've never noticed
this, but this is what Canon claims), and it is unnecessarily using
battery power.
- Finally, not all of Canon's IS lenses use the same IS technology; many
of the more expensive and newer lenses are better, but it was hard enough
for me to come up with what this lens cost--it'll be awhile before I can
rationalize three times as much for an upgrade.
One last note about third-party lenses, in case you're thinking about it.
I know the price may be compelling but there genuinely does seem to be
major quality differences, and while all Canon EOS lenses work will all
Canon EOS cameras, no matter how many years apart they are in design, it
has happened several times that even the best of the third party lenses
(Sigma, some others) do not function properly with new Canon cameras. I
happily buy knock-offs with other things, but not with lenses, flashes, or
other camera components that actually communicate with my camera.
________________________________________________________________
   
Excellent Walkabout Lens, June 20, 2003
Reviewer: Andrew Simmons
While I considered purchasing a Canon 10D, I also started looking for a
good first lens. Most of the reviewers and Canonites on the various forums
suggested this lens as a good starting point.
The 28-135mm IS USM Zoom is the one I use all the time now on the Canon
10D, and that will be the case until I get over the sticker shock of the
10D/28--135mm combo and start adding other lenses to my kit.
In the meantime, this lens gets the job done very well. It gives you good
range for a variety of of shots, from portraits to telephotos. There is
even a macro mode, which gives you the opportunity to do close-ups--not
really a true macro, but okay for shots of flowers, your kitty cat's face,
etc. It is the flexibility of this lens that makes it so appealing if all
you have is just one lens. And remember that if you mount this lens on a
digital camera, like the 10D, the range is actually extended by a factor
of 1.6.
The USM focuses fast, and the Image Stabilization (IS) really works. In
fact, I've been spoiled by it, and IS is now a must for any of the longer
lenses I might purchase in the future.
The IS system "locks" on target so that camera shake is eliminated or at
least seriously minimized. This means fewer shots ruined by camera shake,
and the IS system allows the user to shoot handheld at slower shutter
speeds. This isn't just advertising hype. It works.
The image quality is quite good. I get good color saturation, contrast,
and sharpness. After tweaking some shots in Photoshop, I was able to turn
out some excellent 13x19 inch prints.
As others have pointed out, if you are just starting out with a Canon DSLR
or SLR and want one good general purpose lens, this is it.
Read more
Product Reviews
|